Skip to content

MLS Cup Playoffs Round One Game 1 Recap & Highlights: Portland Timbers at FC Dallas

The Portland Timbers' playoff journey gets off to a rough start as a poor second half dooms them to a game 1 loss

MLS Cup Playoffs Round One Game 1 Recap & Highlights: Portland Timbers at FC Dallas
Photo Credit: Craig Mitchelldyer/Portland Timbers FC

The Portland Timbers fell in game 1 in the first round of the MLS Cup Playoffs, dropping a 3-0 result to FC Dallas on the road in Frisco. An even an encouraging first half gave way to a nightmare of a second half, where Dallas rocked Portland with two goals in two minutes, and then coasted to a 1-0 series lead.

Lineups

Marti Cifuents went with experience and form for his first playoff starting XI. A lot of familiar faces were included: Finn Surman and Joel Waterman lined up together at centerback, the fearsome front three of Kristoffer Velde, Vincent Janssen, and Ariel Lassiter remained intact, and David Da Costa lined up in the middle to pull the strings.

Jose Caicedo got the start at defensive mid, and Cole Bassett reclaimed his starting spot on the right side of the midfield.

It was a classic, "if it ain't broke don'e fix it" lineup from Marti, and for as good as Eric Izoita has been I completely understand inserting the veteran Cole Bassett for what was sure to be a tough away game to kick off the postseason.

Recap & Highlights

In case you were worried about Portland playing conservative and hanging back in their first playoff game under Marti Cifuentes, the Timbers put those worries to rest almost immediately. From the jump Portland was pressing FCD high and often, aiming to dominate possession.

Early on, Dallas were accommodating to that game plan. And that wasn't by accident: the Burn have made conceding possession their calling card all season. The home side looked content to sit deep in banks of four or five to deny Portland entry into the box, and then look to hit the Timbers on the counterrattack.

That was the script that the opening 15 minutes of the game followed. Portland enjoyed stints of possession, but couldn't find a way through Dallas' organized rest defense. Going the other way, the Hoops tried to exploit their speed advantage in wide areas and burn Portland on the wing.

It was via that avenue that Dallas produced the first flashpoint in the series.

17' Save POR – Pantemis
Daniel Job, who was proving to be a handful for Ronald Hernandez all afternoon, came blazing down Portland's right side and into the box. He cut in and tried to take it himself, having his initial shot blocked from close range. A instant rebound forced a split-second reaction save out of James Pantemis, who pushed away the danger.

One of the x-factors in this series is the play of Pantemis, Portland's iron man for the season. His shot stopping has bailed Portland out of so many situations throughout the regular season, and he would surely be asked to do the same against Dallas, up to and including his big stop early on.

After surviving the first real stretch of danger from Dallas, Portland would force a save via a shot of their own from a somewhat unlikely source.

24' Shot POR – Hernandez
Portland gathered the ball and had an extended period of possession around the top of Dallas' box. An initial cross from Bassett was cleared rather awkwardly, and it fell to Ronald Hernandez at the edge of the area. Hernandez took a chance on the half-volley, forcing a save out of Daniel as he pushed away the bouncing shot.

The first half would ebb and flow in that manner for much of the first half. For all of the penetration that Dallas was able to generate, Finn Surman and Joel Waterman seemed to have good control of their own box. Offensively, Portland could work the ball into decent positions – but they were immediately met by the sturdy defensive lines of Dallas.

Perhaps motivated by that lack of penetration, or perhaps by some unseen injury picked up without our knowledge, Cifuentes made a surprising early change.

33' Sub POR: ON Alexander Aravena // OFF Ariel Lassiter
A perplexing early change, as it did not appear that Ari was carrying a knock. He was fouled in the 30th minute, but he showed very little if any signs of it bothering him.

At halftime, Lassiter was seen walking off with his left hamstring iced and wrapped, which may have been the motivation for the sub,

For whatever the reason, Aravena was next up to line up on Portland's right side to try to break the deadlock.

And minutes later, the Timbers came inches away from doing just that.

35' Shot POR – Bassett
David Da Costa broke forward with room to operate. He laid the ball off for Janssen, whose initial shot through traffic was blocked. Bassett was first on the seen to slam the rebound on goal, and it was only a well-made reaction save from Daniel through traffic that denied Cole the opener.

The final fifteen minutes of the half were marked by Portland pouring it on and turning the screw on FC Dallas, coming oh so agonizingly close to grabbing the lead.

40' Shot POR – Bassett
Some good holdup play from Jannseen released Aravena in space, and he cut the ball back for Bassett at the top of the box. From near the same position of Hernandez's shot earlier in the half, Cole had a wallop from distance that Daniel just got his fingertips to and pushed off the far post.

45'+1 Shot POR – Velde
Kristoffer Velde, who found himself getting double-teamed by defenders practically all game, finally found a bit of daylight to operate on the left side of the box. Velde fizzed in a trademark curler towards the far post that sailed just inches away from the post.

Portland really came that close to grabbing a lead. But grab the lead they could not, and the teams went into the locker room deadlocked at zeroes.

HALFTIME: Dallas 0, Timbers 0

Portland held the edge in possession (54%-46%), shots (6-4), and shots on goal (3-1) over the Burn. On the balance of play, the Timbers were the team that deserved to be in the lead rather than the home side. But in the playoffs the margins are so fine, and the Timbers found themselves on the wrong side of them in the first half of the playoffs.

The optimist's view of the first half was that Portland was very close to a breakthrough, and it was only a matter of time before they found the back of the net. The pessimist's view however was that they threw their best shot at Dallas, and it wasn't enough.

The pivotal second half of game 1 would be the definitive statement on which narrative would prevail.

Through the opening ten minutes of the second half, the latter unfortunately looked like it was proving true.

47' Block POR – Surman
Dallas came out of the locker room blazing, and immediately caught the Timbers on their heels. A cutback by Job found Binyamin at the top of the box, and his shot was blocked by the sterling Finn Surman, who was an his usual level of top-tier excellence all game.

48' Save POR – Pantemis
Pants came up huge again to block a shot from Joaquin Valiente, who was sprung in behind by Petar Musa. Joel Waterman slipped trying to intercept the pass, but Pantemis was there to deny the tap-in.

For all of the heroics of Portland's backline, that combo of Musa and Valiente would prove to be their undoing as Dallas cemented their early domination in the second half.

53' Goal DAL – Valiente (1-0)
Musa played in Job, who continued his terrorizing of Hernandez on Portland's right wing. He cut inside and got off a shot, which Pantemis got down to save. But the rebound fell to Valiente, who tapped home the opener.

55' Goal DAL – Valiente (2-0)
Musa was once again the provider as he once again played in Job down Portland's right flank. Job raced to the end line and cut back towards the near post, and Valiente was there to race in and flick it between Pantemis' legs into the net to double the hosts' advantage.

It was an absolutely brutal ten minute stretch for the Timbers, and undid all of the good work they had done in the first half.

Dallas were the ones that came out of the locker room looking much more determined in the second half, and Portland were rocked on their heels from the jump. Tactically, Musa dropping deep pulled Surman and Waterman deeper and more central, isolating Hernandez on the wing with Job. And so, Dallas pressed an advantage they had had all game and turned it into two goals.

They almost got a third an hour into the matchup.

60' Save POR – Pantemis
Finn Surman whiffed on a through ball, and the speedy Valiente raced ahead to latch onto the loose ball and continue in on goal. Pantemis made a great sliding save with his right arm to limit the damage for Portland.

Cifuentes had then seen enough, and made a triple-change to try to stop the bleeding.

64' Subs POR: ON Omir Fernandez, Eric Izoita, Diego Chara // OFF: Ronald Hernandez, Cole Bassett, Jose Caicedo
Marti refreshed his midfield with Chara and Izoita, and plugged Omir Fernandez into right back in an attempt to try to stop the marauding Job from causing more pain for Portland.

And based on the play that occurred minutes after he subbed on when Fernandez stonewalled and won the ball back from Job one-on-one, it appeared it was the right move.

Still, Portland suddenly found themselves trailing by two goals. They needed to try to find that same offensive spark that they had in the first half, and put pressure on Daniel in an attempt to find an avenue back into the game.

But unfortunately, the Timbers could not rediscover what made the first half so promising. Their first shot of the second half wasn't until the 66th minute, when they were already down by two goals.

Still, Portland battled on, knowing that just one goal could change things. But they couldn't really get much of a sniff on goal until the dying embers.

Which made how excruciatingly close the came all the more painful.

82' Shot POR – Aravena
Alex Aravena worked himself into a pocket of space at the top of the box and whipped a curler on frame. It took a touch off a Dallas defender's boot, then pinged off the underside of the crossbar, then off the post and out. Three touches & deflections, never crossing the line. Like I said: excruciating.

85' Shot POR – Surman & Janssen
Off a corner hick, Surman powered a header on frame. It took a deflection off Janssen and spiraled on frame, but Daniel was quick to pounce on it and snuff out the chaos.

In the end, Portland could only manage one shot on target through the entirety of the second half. The quality of the chances they generated nosedived, and Dallas adjusted well to crack open Portland's defense and put the game state in their favor.

In second half stoppage time, FCD slammed the door shut.

90'+4 Goal DAL – Sarver (3-0)
Second half substitute Sam Sarver tapped home a cross after Dallas came flying forward on the break. With Portland pushing so many bodies forward, there were sparse defensive reinforcements to cover the entry ball before Sarver could score.

The final whistle blew a few minutes later, and the result was official: Portland fell after a poor second half in game 1.

FULL TIME: Dallas 3, Timbers 0

After such a promising opening half, the limp second half performance hit like a ton of bricks and kind of came out of nowhere. Portland coming out of the locker room on their heels in the first half was one thing, but their inability to adjust and recover was quite disappointing.

Credit where it is due: FC Dallas made some smart adjustments in the second half to punish the Timbers. Musa, who was kept well in check by Surman and Waterman in the first half, turned into the distributor by dropping deeper to link up play. That allowed Job to exploit his speed advantage over Hernandez one-on-one, and in the blink of an eye it was 2-0.

It might be simplistic to say that that two minute stretch took all of the wind out of Portland's sails, but that really feels like what happened. The offense becoming absent in the second half was almost as discouraging as the defense getting brutalized out of the break. And altogether, it was a disappointing Timbers performance on the road.

The upshot is that the series is not over. The action shifts next Saturday to Providence Park and a friendly crowd. Portland has a chance in game 2 to capitalize on the types of opportunities they created in the first half today, and ride the energy of a home Providence Park crowd to a stronger performance.

If Portland learns and adjusts from their deficiencies today, it could be enough to earn them another game back in Frisco in two weeks.

But if they can't, then the season could be over in just a week's time. It's still all to play for next weekend at Providence Park.

Sam Svilar

Sam Svilar

Soccer is cool. Smashing toxic masculinity is cooler. Diego Valeri is the coolest. #RCTID since I was a ball boy once in 2009. #BAONPDX since 2013.

All articles

More in Portland Timbers

See all

More from Sam Svilar

See all